Technology in Nursing Impact of Technology on Nursing Education
Technology and Educational Innovations in Nursing
The landscape of teaching in nursing education has undergone significant transformation with the integration of new technologies. However, the rapid adoption of these technologies in the past has often occurred without adequate planning or understanding of their pedagogical implications, leading to several initial difficulties. Despite these challenges, self-directed learning encouraged by these technologies has been shown to be equivalent or even superior to traditional methods of instruction (Armstrong & Frueh, 2003).
This topic explores the use of various technologies such as the Internet, CD-ROMs, and simulation tools in nursing education and evaluates their effectiveness in fostering self-directed learning. It also discusses the advantages and disadvantages of both traditional and innovative teaching methods.
Technology-Related Teaching Challenges
Technological issues with course delivery and reduced student satisfaction with web-based versus traditional delivery methods have been reported by numerous nurse educators (Billings, 2000; Cragg, 1994a; Cragg, 1994b; DeBourgh, 2003; Ryan, Carlton, & Ali, 1999; Yucha & Princen, 2000). The inconsistency of basic Internet skills among students and the lack of standardization of web browsers, platforms, and computers within student groups are significant sources of dissatisfaction with web-based course delivery (DeBourgh, 2003).
Additionally, students have frequently expressed dissatisfaction with the visual appeal and interface design of course websites (DeBourgh, 2003; Rouse, 1999). Interface design concerns how screen elements are used to navigate an application and provide access to media content (Ribbons, 1998). Furthermore, unstable or poorly performing Internet course software can significantly undermine student satisfaction with web-based course delivery (Ayoub, Vanderboom, Knight, Walsh, Briggs, & Grekin, 1998; Block, Pollock, & Hutton, 1999; DeBourgh, 2003; Milstead & Nelson, 1998).
Benefits of Technology-Related Approaches
Internet-based learning occurs in a virtual classroom, offering flexibility that allows students to learn anytime, anywhere, provided they have access to a computer. This flexibility addresses some of the educational barriers for nurses and nursing students in clinical settings, such as irregular work schedules (McAlpine, Lockerbie, Ramsay, & Beaman, 2002) or limited time (Reinert & Fryback, 1997).
Test results from Internet-based courses have demonstrated similar or higher-than-average scores compared to traditional classroom courses (Andrusyszyn, Iwasiw, & Goldenberg, 1999; Billings, Skiba, & Connors, 2005). Additionally, studies have indicated that Internet-based group discussions are deeper and more diverse than equivalent classroom-based interactions, with outcomes that meet or exceed those of classroom courses (Billings, Skiba, & Connors, 2005; Cravener, 1999; Ryan, Carlton, & Ali, 1999).
Internet-based courses can enhance student participation by allowing a greater number of students to engage in discussions (Bangert, 2005). Unlike traditional classroom settings, where students may need to compete for recognition or the chance to speak, Internet-based environments provide time for thoughtful responses. According to Billings and Rowles (2001), methods such as dialogue, discussions, writing assignments, mini-lectures, games, and critical thinking exercises work well in online settings because all participants must engage actively, unlike in traditional classrooms where passive learning can occur.
Benefits of Multimedia and Simulators in Nursing Education
Multimedia CD-ROMs can circumvent some of the problems encountered in web-based learning, such as issues with Internet service providers (ISPs), insufficient home Internet infrastructure, or web course failures. Additionally, CD-ROMs generally require less technical knowledge, reducing the time students might otherwise spend learning new computer skills and allowing them to focus on course content (Cravener, 1999; Geibert, 2000; Leasure, Davis, & Thievon, 2000).
CD-ROM learning offers active learning experiences combined with prompt feedback, helping learners to assess what they know and identify gaps in their understanding (Jeffries, 2000). However, CD-ROM development projects have often faced criticism from students who desire more detailed coverage of additional topics (Marshall & van Soeren, 2000). Educators who have piloted or tested CD-ROM-based instruction suggest using CD-ROMs as a supplement to other types of instruction that provide more faculty-student interaction (Bauer, Geront, & Huynh, 2001; Jeffries, 2000; Madorin & Iwasiw, 1999; Wells et al., 2003).
Simulators can create realistic learning experiences that reinforce content and increase learner confidence in managing clinical situations. Simulations may include using mannequins (e.g., for cardiopulmonary resuscitation practice), sequences of skills with models like an intravenous practice arm, human simulation through role-playing, and highly advanced interactive patient simulators (Billings & Halstead, 2005).
In active simulation, the instructor serves as both a role model and coach. During student-directed practice sessions, the traditional role of the instructor can be supplemented with a technology-mediated, self-directed learning approach. The ability to adjust simulation activities to match or slightly exceed the student’s current knowledge and skills makes simulation particularly effective as a tailored teaching strategy (Lupien & George-Gay, 2001).
Traditional Versus Innovative Teaching Methods: Pros and Cons
Traditional Methods: Advantages and Disadvantages
Advantages:
Traditional teaching methods, such as face-to-face lectures and hands-on demonstrations, provide direct interaction between educators and students, allowing for immediate feedback and clarification. These methods are familiar to both educators and students, often making them easier to implement and manage. They also facilitate social learning, where students learn from observing and interacting with peers.
Disadvantages:
Traditional methods may not accommodate all learning styles, particularly in large classroom settings where personalized attention is limited. Additionally, they may not provide the flexibility needed by many nursing students who juggle work, family, and academic responsibilities. These methods can also be less effective in fostering self-directed learning, which is critical in a rapidly changing healthcare environment.
Innovative Methods: Advantages and Disadvantages
Advantages:
Innovative teaching methods, such as online learning, multimedia, and simulations, offer flexibility, accessibility, and the potential for personalized learning. They can support self-directed learning and allow students to learn at their own pace. These methods also often incorporate interactive elements, making learning more engaging and effective.
Disadvantages:
The implementation of innovative teaching methods requires significant technological infrastructure and support. There may be a learning curve for both educators and students, and not all students may have equal access to the necessary technology. Furthermore, these methods may sometimes lack the human element present in traditional face-to-face learning, which is essential for developing certain interpersonal and clinical skills.
Conclusion
The integration of technology into nursing education provides numerous opportunities for enhancing learning experiences. It encourages the use of evidence-based practices, promotes critical thinking, and prepares nursing students for the demands of a technologically advanced healthcare system. However, educators must balance the use of traditional and innovative methods, considering their respective advantages and disadvantages, to create an inclusive and effective learning environment that caters to diverse learning needs. By combining both approaches, nursing education can effectively equip future nurses with the skills and knowledge they need to succeed in a dynamic and complex healthcare landscape.